Pittsburgh City Paper Booze Battles: New Amsterdam vs. Proper Brick Oven and Tap Room | Booze Battles | Pittsburgh | Pittsburgh City Paper

Pittsburgh City Paper Booze Battles: New Amsterdam vs. Proper Brick Oven and Tap Room 


  • CP photos by Celine Roberts

Each week, we order the same cocktail at two different bars for a friendly head-to-head battle. Go to the bars, taste them both and tell us what you like about each by tagging @pghcitypaper on Twitter or Instagram and using #CPBoozeBattles. If you want to be a part of Booze Battles, send an email to food-and-beverage writer Celine Roberts, at celine@pghcitypaper.com

New Amsterdam

4421 Butler St., Lawrenceville

Drink: Kingston Sidecar

Ingredients: Appleton Estate Reserve blend rum, house-infused orange liqueur, lemon juice, fresh strawberry preserves, peach bitters and orange twist

Our take: The rum and strawberry preserves give this cocktail a sweet and jammy kick, while the bright tart flavors of lemon and orange counterbalance the sweetness. The resulting combination is almost salty, and this cocktail feels like a deserved dessert at the end of a long day.


Proper Brick Oven and Tap Room

139 Seventh St., Downtown

Drink: Proper Sidecar

Ingredients: Laird’s Applejack brandy, lemon juice, Cointreau, orange peel and a cinnamon-sugar rim

Our take: One of the only drinks I’ve ever had that was well served by a sugared rim, this cocktail is perfect for warming up. The brandy provides strong apple flavors, and paired with the warmth of the cinnamon and orange, it really shines. 



Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment


CP Newsletters

Sign up to get the freshest content sent right to your inbox.

No recent CP TV

© 2018 Pittsburgh City Paper

Website powered by Foundation

National Advertising by VMG Advertising