Best Mushroom Gummies of 2024 | Tested & Reviewed | Pittsburgh City Paper

Best Mushroom Gummies: Top 5 Brands To Buy Mushroom Gummies Online In 2024

Picture taking a magic mushroom gummy and setting off on a flavorful journey that sparks your mental imagery.

A single magic mushroom gummy transports you to a universe of boundless creativity, releasing your inner curiosity while providing a unique perspective on the world around you.

While these gummies are a way to break free from the ordinary and explore the endless corridors of your mind, many brands online don’t offer pure and safe magic mushroom gummies, making it difficult to choose among the plethora of options available in the market.

After testing 25+ brands, we have curated a list of the top 7 magic mushroom brands that bring their unique blend of flavors and effects, ensuring a truly unforgettable journey.

Whether you're a seasoned psychonaut or a curious beginner, these top 7 brands assure an immersive and mind-expanding experience.

7 Best Sites To Buy Magic Mushroom Gummies In 2024

  • Exhale Wellness: Overall Best Magic Mushroom Gummies
  • Budpop: Most Potent Magic Mushroom Gummies
  • Riti- Best Functional Mushroom Gummies for cognitive function
  • Cheef Botanicals- Best Mushroom Gummies for Anxiety & Stress
  • CBDFx- CBD-Infused Mushroom Gummies
  • Elm & Rye- High-Quality Mushroom Gummies
  • SUKU Vitamins- Affordable Mushroom Gummy Brand

#1. Exhale Wellness: Overall Best Magic Mushroom Gummies

Holding the #1 spot on our list, Exhale's Amanita Mushroom Gummies are the perfect option to push the limits of your mind without spending a fortune.

Made with natural plant-based ingredients, these mushroom gummies are infused with 5 mg of Muscimol and 500 mg of Amanita Muscaria Fruiting Body Extract per gummy, ensuring a consistent and effective dosage.

These magic mushroom gummies are also third-party lab-tested to guarantee purity and potency, giving users peace of mind knowing they are consuming high-quality shroom gummies.

Many users described that after taking ½ gummy, they began experiencing alterations in perception, heightened creativity, euphoria, relaxation, and a sense of interconnectedness with the universe within 20–40 minutes, lasting up to 4-6 hours.


  • 5 Amanita gummy cubes per pack

  • Assorted fruity flavors

  • No artificial coloring or flavors

  • 3 varieties of magic mushroom gummies


  • Delivery is not available in some states


  • Individual: $34.95

  • 2-Pack: $64.66

  • 3-Pack: $89.12

=> Click here to visit the official website “Exhale Wellness”

#2 Budpop: Most Potent Magic Mushroom Gummies

Looking to unwind and reconnect with yourself amidst life's hustle and bustle? Budpop's Amanita Mushroom Gummies provide a delightful escape from the chaos of everyday life.

Made with high-quality Amanita Muscaria Extract, these gummies provide a natural and gentle way to relax your mind and body. These chewy treats are pre-dosed and offer a convenient option for those seeking a calming experience without the hassle of measuring or preparing.

Each pack contains 5 gummies with 25mg of Muscimol and 2500 mg of Amanita muscaria Fruiting Body Extract, allowing you to control your dosage easily.

You can be confident that each batch of these magic mushroom gummies has undergone rigorous third-party lab testing to ensure their potency and purity.

This guarantees you are consuming safe and pure mushroom gummies, giving you peace of mind while indulging in your well-deserved moment of tranquility.


  • Potent & pure shroom gummies

  • Free shipping over $99

  • 100% federally Legal

  • Orders placed early are shipped the same day


  • Only available on the official website


  • Single: $34.95

  • 2-Pack: $64.66

  • 3-Pack: $89.12

=> Click here to visit the official website “Budpop”

#3. Riti - Best Functional Mushroom Gummies For Cognitive Function

Riti mushroom gummies are one of the best mushroom gummies, which are a perfect blend of 10 different high-quality mushroom types like Lion’s Mane Mushroom and Reishi Mushroom, among others. These gummies are juicy, and you can taste the flavors of different mushrooms in every bite.

These mushroom gummies are available in various sizes, come in a tasty raspberry flavor, and have several health benefits. These gummies are good for digestive health, can enhance your mood, and improve energy levels. Also, the Riti mushroom gummy supplement can boost your immune system and increase focus and cognitive function.


  • Made of 10 different mushrooms

  • Vegan and Non-GMO

  • Third-party tested

  • Made from high-quality ingredients


  • Available in only a single flavor


  • Single pack- $49.95

  • Pack of 2- $89.91

  • Pack of 3- $127.37

=> Click here to visit the official website “Riti”

4. Cheef Botanicals - Best Mushroom Gummies For Anxiety & Stress

Cheef Botanicals offers 3 different mushroom gummies, namely Immunity Gummy Cubes, Wellness Gummy Cubes, and Brain Boost Gummies. The Immunity Mushroom Blend is made of Chaga, Reishi, and Turkey mushroom. Lion’s Mane and Reishi are used in the Brain Boost Mushroom Blend. The Wellness Mushroom Blend comprises the extracts of Cordyceps, Lion’s Mane, Chaga, and Reishi mushrooms.

Cheef Botanicals sources powerful compounds from the cap and stem of the mushrooms and uses cane sugar and tapioca syrup for natural sweetness. You can consume these mushroom gummies daily as they ease swelling and relieve fatigue. These gummies also ease your stress and anxiety.


  • Made with natural ingredients

  • Vegan mushroom gummies

  • Assorted fruity flavors

  • Doesn’t contain artificial coloring or flavors


  • Might take a few days to show effects


  • Single pack- $14.95

  • Pack of 2- $29.90

  • Pack of 3- $44.85

=> Click here to visit the official website “Cheef Botanicals”

5. CBDfx - CBD-Infused Mushroom Gummies

CBDfx mushroom gummies are one of the best mushroom gummies as they contain CBD and are made of mushroom extracts. Every gummy has 7.1mg of mushroom extract and 25mg of broad-spectrum CBD. These gummies are relatively delicious.

CBDfx mushroom gummies contain high-quality shrooms like Lion's Mane, Chaga, Maitake, Shiitake, Turkey Tail, Cordyceps, and Reishi. They are made of only vegan and organic materials and are great health supplements. These gummies are highly nutritious, contain antioxidants, and boost your energy.


  • Tasty cherry flavor

  • Non-GMO and certified organic materials

  • No residual chemicals

  • Contains 5+ mushrooms


  • Might be unavailable in some states.


  • Single pack- $54.99

  • Pack of 2- $104.49

=> Click here to visit the official website “CBDfx”

6. Elm & Rye - High-Quality Mushroom Gummies

Elm&Rye are known for offering mushroom gummies in various forms, such as capsules, gummies, and coffee creams. Lion's Mane, Maitake, Chaga, Reishi, and Cordyceps are used in these gummies. They are nutritious and increase your overall well-being.

These mushroom gummies are made using only high-quality ingredients and are lab-tested. Sugar and glucose syrup are used for sweetness. If you subscribe to Elm&Rye, you can save 25% on these gummies and exclusive discounts on other products.


  • Available in single, 2-pack, and 4-packs

  • Third-party tested

  • Contains pectin instead of gelatin

  • Free shipping in the US over $99


  • Contains sugar and vegetable oil.


  • Single pack- $44.99

  • Monthly subscription delivery (single pack)- $33.74

=> Click here to visit the official website “Elm&Rye”

7. SUKU Vitamins - Affordable Mushroom Gummy Brand

Mushroom gummies from SUKU Vitamins are the best budget-friendly gummies, which combine Turkey Tail, Reishi, Chaga, and Lion's Mane extracts. These gummies are fibrous, contain natural sweetness, and are sugar-free.

These mushroom gummies come in a mild coffee flavor and are quite delicious. Comprised of four different mushrooms, namely reishi, chaga, turkey tail, and lion’s name, these gummies are a great source of antioxidants and fungal polysaccharides with immunomodulating properties.


  • Affordable mushroom gummies

  • Delicious coffee flavor

  • Contains 4 potent mushrooms

  • No sugar or sugar alcohol


  • Available in only one flavor.


  • Single pack- $12.80

=> Click here to visit the official website “SUKU Vitamins”

How We Created The List Of Best Magic Mushroom Gummies?

As hundreds of magic mushroom gummy brands are available on the market, we have created our own standards to review different brands to find the best ones. Here are the criteria we followed to curate this list of the top 7 magic mushroom gummy brands.


We evaluated the efficacy of each magic mushroom gummy by considering its impact on mood enhancement, relaxation, and overall well-being. We prioritized brands that use high-quality magic mushroom extracts in their gummies, ensuring you get the most out of each dose.

We placed reliable brands like Exhale higher on the list, which provided long-lasting results with just one gummy while avoiding discomfort or unintended side effects.

Brand Reputation

We selected only those brands that prioritized customer satisfaction, provided excellent customer service, and had a track record of delivering high-quality magic mushroom gummies, ensuring consumers a safe and enjoyable experience.

Thousands of satisfied customers have rated these brands 4.5 out of 5 stars and have given them favorable reviews for their consistent product quality and potency.


We looked for brands that offered a variety of flavors to suit different palates. These brands include Budpop, which provides an assortment of flavors from tangy to sweet in a single pack. So, you can enjoy a variety of taste experiences with just one purchase.

Whether you prefer fruity flavors or something more unique, these brands have options to satisfy every taste preference.


While affordability is important, we considered brands such as Exhale and Cheef Botanicals that offer cost-effective models like one-time purchase and save & subscribe, allowing customers to choose the option that best fits their budget and needs.

Additionally, these brands prioritize transparency by providing detailed information about their sourcing and manufacturing processes, ensuring customers can make informed decisions about the gummiesthey purchase.

How To Choose The Best Magic Mushroom Gummies?

When selecting the best magic mushroom gummies to incorporate into your wellness routine, you should consider several key factors to ensure safety, quality, and effectiveness. Here's a breakdown of important considerations to remember:


Ensure your magic mushroom gummies contain high-quality natural ingredients and use premium mushroom extracts such as Amanita Muscaria or Psilocybin. Pay attention to additional ingredients used for flavoring or sweetening, ensuring they are free from any artificial additives, preservatives, or fillers.

Brand Value

Opt for well-established brands with a record of creating high-quality, effective, and flavorfulmushroom gummies. These brands commit to sustainability, transparency in sourcing, and adherence to ethical practices.

Third-Party Lab Tested

Look for brands that have undergone third-party testing by independent laboratories and provide certificates of analysis (COA), ensuring that every batch of their mushroom gummies has been rigorously assessed for potency, purity, and safety.

Potency and Dosage

When selecting any magic mushroom gummies, it's crucial to consider their potency and the recommended consumption dosage. The average serving size for a mushroom gummy is 1/2 to 1 gummy.

For instance, Exhale's Amanita Magic Mushroom Gummies contain 5 mg of Muscimol per gummy, providing a moderate potency for users. Remember to always start with a lower dose and gradually increase as needed to assess your body's response and tolerance.


Compare the pricing of different mushroom gummies to ensure you're getting good value. Remember that higher prices don't always correlate with better quality, so prioritize brands that balance affordability and quality.

Customer Reviews

Read customer reviews and testimonials to gain insight into your fellow users' experiences with the mushroom gummies. Customers highly recommend Exhale and Budpop for their potent and flavorful mushroom gummies that provide a smooth and enjoyable psychedelic experience.

How Do Magic Mushroom Gummies Work?

Mushroom gummies typically work by delivering the active compounds found in mushrooms, such as psilocybin or other beneficial compounds like beta-glucans, in a convenient and edible form.

When ingested, these gummies are broken down in the digestive system, allowing the active ingredients to be absorbed into the bloodstream. Once in the bloodstream, the compounds can travel to the brain and other body parts, where they exert their effects.

For example, in the case of psilocybin-containing mushroom gummies, psilocybin interacts with serotonin receptors in the brain, leading to altered perceptions, mood changes, and sometimes profound insights or spiritual experiences.

Overall, mushroom gummies offer a convenient and controlled way to experience the benefits of magic mushrooms, whether for relaxation, creativity, spiritual exploration, or general well-being.

Benefits Of Taking Magic Mushroom Gummies

Some of the primary benefits of consuming magic mushroom gummies are listed below:

1. Ease of Consumption
  • Gummies are discreet and portable, offering a convenient and palatable way to enjoy the benefits of magic mushrooms without drawing any unwanted attention.

2. Precise Dosage
  • The consistent and precise dosage of magic mushroom gummies promotes a safer and more controlled psychedelic experience, mitigating the risk of accidentally taking too much or too little.

3. Gradual Onset and Duration
  • These gummies typically have a slower onset compared to other forms of ingestion, allowing users to ease into the psychedelic experience gradually.

  • The effects of gummies also tend to last longer, providing a sustained experience that can be enjoyed over several hours without frequent redosing.

4. Reduced Gastrointestinal Distress
  • Taking magic mushrooms in gummy form can help minimize the gastrointestinal discomfort often associated with ingesting raw mushrooms or brewed tea.

  • The jelly texture of gummies may be easier on the stomach, making them a more tolerable option for individuals prone to nausea or digestive issues.

5. Diverse Flavor Options
  • Magic mushroom gummies come in various flavors, making them more appealing to users who may find the taste of raw mushrooms unpalatable.

FAQs About Magic Mushroom Gummies

Q1. What are magic mushroom gummies?

Magic mushroom gummies are delightful treats infused with extracts from psychedelic mushrooms like Amanita muscaria or psilocybin. They offer a convenient and tasty way to experience the therapeutic effects of these mushrooms, such as enhanced mood, creativity, and introspection.

Q2. What are the side effects of magic mushroom gummies?

Side effects of magic mushroom gummies are typically mild and may include nausea, dizziness, and changes in perception. However, when consumed responsibly and in moderation, most users report positive experiences and minimal discomfort.

Q3. Are magic mushroom gummies safe to take every day?

Although you could be an experienced user, we don’t recommend you take magic mushroom gummies daily. Daily use can lead to tolerance buildup and diminishing effects over time. For beginners, it is important to start with a low dosage and gradually increase it to gauge your tolerance and reaction to the substance.

Q4. Are magic mushroom gummies legal?

The legality of Magic Mushroom Gummies varies by location. In some areas of the U.S., they are legal for medicinal or recreational use, while in others, they may be restricted or prohibited. Researching and adhering to local laws and regulations before purchasing or consuming them is essential.

Q5. Do magic mushroom gummies help with anxiety and depression?

Yes, many studies and research available today show that magic mushroom gummies do help with anxiety and depression, providing a sense of calm, clarity, and emotional relief. However, dosage plays a huge role in deciding the effects.

Q6. Who should avoid taking magic mushroom gummies?

People with a history of mental health issues, such as psychosis or bipolar disorder, should avoid taking magic mushroom gummies. Additionally, pregnant or nursing mothers and individuals taking certain medications may need to exercise caution.

Q7. What is the best time of day to take magic mushroom gummies?

The best time of day to take magic mushroom gummies depends on your personal preferences and lifestyle. Some users prefer to consume them in the morning to start their day with a positive mindset, while others find that taking them in the evening promotes relaxation and restful sleep.

Concluding Thoughts About The Best Magic Mushroom Gummies Available Online

Magic mushroom gummies are the perfect way to experience psychedelic effects in a fun and convenient form. These gummies are infused with carefully measured doses, ensuring a consistent and controlled experience.

Exhale and Budpop stand out as the best brands on our list of top 7 magic mushroom gummies. Both brands have gained a reputation for their high-quality ingredients and rigorous testing processes, ensuring that each gummy delivers a potent and safe psychedelic experience.

So, check out the brands on our list and let your creativity soar with magic mushroom gummies, meticulously crafted to deliver an enjoyable psychedelic experience anywhere and anytime.

Disclaimer: Pittsburgh City Paper does not endorse or practice services described in paid content.