232 S. Highland Ave., Shadyside
412-404-8853 or www.millieshomemade.com
Made from milk and eggs from Western Pennsylvania farms, Millie’s sells several varieties of ice cream at local grocery stores and from their scoop shop. Flavors change seasonally, but favorites include chocolate, vanilla and salted caramel.
2nd: Klavon’s Ice Cream
3rd: Dave and Andy’s Homemade Ice Cream