246 Forbes Ave., Downtown (412-709-6579)
232 S. Highland Ave., Shadyside (412-404-8853)
The carefully curated flavors, from the aptly named The Best Chocolate to cantaloupe tarragon, signals Millie’s gourmet aspirations at its two scoop shops and numerous area retailers and eateries. The milk, eggs and seasonal flavorings are locally sourced; heck, this ice cream is even pasteurized in-house.
2nd: Page Dairy Mart, South Side
3rd: Sarris Candies, Canonsburg