Can a drinking game be trademarked? Local musician Ali Spagnola hopes not. 

Ali Spagnola expected to raise eyebrows by releasing an album of 60 one-minute songs about drinking, entitled Power Hour, and turning her shows into a bring-your-own-shot-glass drinking game. She certainly didn't expect backlash from a fellow power-hour entrepreneur. 

"Power hour," as many undergrads can tell you, involves drinking a shot of beer every minute for an hour. Spagnola incorporated the drinking-game idea into her music because she wanted her friends to actually have fun at her shows. "I was playing live at coffee shops and I would get my friends to come and it was really a chore," she says. "You weren't really going to a party -- you were going to a boring recital." Her shows became quite a hit, and she has since released a play-at-home DVD, which includes videos for each of the Liz Phair-esque songs.

But whether Spagnola can legally use the name "Power Hour" is in question. Steve Roose says he has been marketing a DVD game of the same name since 2000 (online at www.powerhourvx.com). Roose recently trademarked the name, and has issued a cease-and-desist order, which would require Spagnola to remove all videos from her website, stop selling her CDs and DVDs, and stop playing power-hour-themed shows.

Roose's DVD, hosted by an animated character called The Beer Man, basically acts as a stop-watch, telling players when to drink, and incorporating dares like "give someone a 'wet willy' or take another shot!"

Spagnola thinks she can challenge Roose's claims. To cover legal expenses, she launched an online fundraising campaign last week at www.alispagnola.com/music, offering a range of incentives, from an album download ($5 donation) to an original song written for the donor ($3,000).

Michael J. Madison, who teaches intellectual-property law at University of Pittsburgh, stresses that no one can trademark a phrase that is merely descriptive. "If 'Power Hour' is a generic description of 'a drinking game that involves drinking a shot of alcohol each minute for an hour,' then Mr. Roose can't have any trademark rights at all."

Winning a case like this, Madison says, usually depends on finding that the trademark holder was not the first to use the phrase to sell or market a product, or that "the trademark isn't actually associated by consumers with a service that the registrant provides." In any case, Madison says, Spagnola might merely need to change the name of her event and DVDs: "He can't stop her from singing or recording one-minute songs."



Showing 1-1 of 1

Add a comment

Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-1 of 1

Add a comment

More by Margaret Welsh


Submit an event


Sign up for Daily Rundown and get the freshest content sent right to your inbox.


Who are you rooting for in the World Series?

  • Cleveland Indians.
  • Chicago Cubs.
  • They're still doing that thing?
  • I don't care and I'm mad that you asked.

View Results

© 2016 Pittsburgh City Paper

Website powered by Foundation

National Advertising by VMG Advertising